One Truck or Build a Fleet? The Pros and Cons of Hiring Drivers

Please note: This is not legal or financial advice and should be used for entertainment purposes only. You absolutely will need to do a deeper dive research on each step and consult with an attorney [or multiple ones] to do this legally and safely. Consider a LegalShield Small Business plan as an option to save on your legal expenses.

Should You Stay Solo or Grow Your Operation?

You’ve got your truck paid off (or close), steady freight coming in, and the thought hits you:

“Maybe it’s time to hire someone and grow this thing.”

But should you?

Many successful owner-operators reach this crossroads. Expanding beyond one truck can mean more profit—but also more pressure. Before you post that job ad or buy another rig, let’s break down the real pros and cons of moving from solo driver to small fleet boss.

---

? PROS: Why Hiring a Driver Can Be a Smart Move

? 1. Increased Revenue Potential

More trucks on the road = more loads delivered. That means more gross income—especially if freight rates are good and you have steady lanes.

⏳ 2. Leverage Your Time

If you’re tired of doing everything yourself, having another driver means:

• You earn money even when you’re not behind the wheel

• You can take time off, deal with family, or focus on managing the business

? 3. Build Equity in a Real Business

Running multiple trucks turns your operation into an asset. If you ever want to:

• Sell your business

• Attract investors

• Pass it to family

…it helps to have something bigger than just your name on a truck.

? 4. Possible Tax Benefits

With multiple trucks, you may gain new deductions, depreciation options, or eligibility for S-corp strategies that can reduce your tax burden (talk to a trucking-savvy CPA).

---

? CONS: Why Staying Solo Might Be the Smarter Play

?‍? 1. Managing Drivers Is a Whole New Job

Hiring means dealing with people—and not every driver will treat your equipment or your reputation the way you do. Expect:

• Call-ins, breakdowns, drama

• Training time and supervision

• HR headaches and paperwork

You stop being “just a trucker” and become a full-time manager.

? 2. Compliance and Insurance Headaches

Adding drivers means more:

• DOT compliance (drug testing, safety audits, logbook tracking)

• Insurance premiums (which can spike for new drivers)

• Legal risk if something goes wrong on the road

It’s a big step up in responsibility and liability.

? 3. More Overhead, Thinner Margins

One truck can be lean and mean. Add more, and you’ve got:

• Another truck payment

• Another trailer (maybe)

• Fuel, maintenance, repairs

• Driver pay, taxes, benefits, workers’ comp

Your revenue goes up, but so do your expenses—and your profit per mile may not.

? 4. Hard to Find and Keep Good Drivers

Let’s face it—it’s tough out there. Many fleets struggle with:

• High driver turnover

• Drivers who ghost or damage equipment

• Safety score issues from bad behavior

Hiring the wrong driver can cost you more than they earn.

---

?So, What’s the Right Move?

Ask yourself:

• Do I want to manage people—or stay focused on the road?

• Do I have reliable freight to justify a second truck?

• Am I ready for the legal, financial, and compliance responsibilities?

• Do I have strong systems (bookkeeping, dispatch, maintenance) already in place?

If you’re running lean, making good money, and enjoying life, there’s nothing wrong with staying solo. Many owner-operators live well and retire comfortably with just one truck.

But if you’re ready to build something bigger—and take on the risk and reward that comes with it—expanding might be the next gear in your growth.

---

?️ Final Thought

Running a one-truck show is trucking freedom. Running a fleet is trucking leadership. Both have value—but only you can decide which lane you want to drive in.

From your friends at TruckStopReport.com:
Plan smart, scale wisely, and always know where you’re headed.